It is important to know the difference between forging and casting since they are the most common metal manufacturing processes that exist. Metal components and products are produced using a variety of methods.
The key difference between forging and casting is that casting involves heating metal to a molten state in a furnace. To form a component shape, the metal is poured into a die, also known as a mold, while it is still liquid.
Whereas, forging involves applying mechanical and thermal energy to ingots which causes the alloy to undergo a form change while it is still solid. Well, in this reading, we’ll explore the difference between casting and forging.
Let’s Get Started!
Casting Vs Forging
Casting
Casting is a process of heating metals to liquid/melt and pouring the molten metal into a cavity in order to take the shape of the cavity in every detail so as to produce an article called casting. It is a very old process of producing any materials with the desired shape. It has been in existence since 6000 years ago. Castings are used to produce complex shapes that cannot be easily manufactured by other manufacturing processes.
The size of the world market for metal casting in 2018 was estimated at $123.8 billion. From 2019 to 2025, this value is projected to increase at a CAGR of 5.3 percent. The automotive industry, which is expected to fuel this market expansion over the next six years, contributes to the rising demand.
Due to the complexity of the components, casting is one of the main methods used to make automobile components. Casting is also used to make complex parts of any machine, they are done in automobile industries, railways, aeroscopes, shipping, etc. for producing different parts.
Casting is used in the electrical aspect of producing items like motors, generators, pumps, compressors, etc. Casting operations are also performed in hardware industries where the production of plumbing pipes, joints, fittings, valves, etc. There are still a lot of items produced with casting. In fact, almost 90% of metal items are produced with casting.
Sand casting is another casting technique. It involves pressing a pattern into a fine sand mixture to create casts. This creates a mold into which the molten metal can be poured. Despite being slow, this casting method is typically more affordable. Additionally, it works well for large metal production projects or when elaborate patterns are required. Below are some common benefits of casting:
- Complex components
- Flexible quantities
- Strength and quality
- Minimized labor Low cost
Forging
Forging is a manufacturing process in which metals are heated to some extent and compressed using external agencies like, hammers, rolls, presses, or upsetting machines to obtain a specific shape.
Forging is used for different purposes and for specific reasons. It is used when an object needs greater strength, high tensile strength, a high degree of surface finish, greater productivity, more reliability, greater dimensional accuracy, greater fatigue strength, etc.
Forging operations are also used when the less complex object is needed and the object with less weight. Forging is commonly used in a project like a piece of railroad equipment, small tools, automobile tools, parts, aviation industries, etc.
Metal is shaped by forging using compressive force. The metal workpiece is struck with a hammer or die until the required shape is created. Forging deforms and molds the metal by pounding it; this creates an uninterrupted grain flow, which keeps the metal’s strength. This particular grain flow has additional benefits, such as removing product flaws, inclusions, and porosity.
The relatively cheap costs associated with moderate and lengthy manufacturing runs are another benefit of forging. Once the forging tools have been developed, goods may be produced with little downtime and at relatively high speeds.
Cold forging is the process of forging metal that is at room temperature. Warm forging, which involves heating the metal to a temperature above room temperature and below the recrystallization temperature, is another method of forging.
The procedure is known as hot forging when the metal is heated to its recrystallization temperature, which varies by metal. One of the earliest forms of manufacturing is forging, which was first used by blacksmiths thousands of years ago. Below are some common benefits of forging:
- Stronger products
- Higher fatigue strength
- Low operating cost
- Variety of shapes accomplished
Difference Between Forging and Casting
Here are some specific differences between forging and casting:
The metal material is heated until it completely melts in the casting process while in forging operations the metal is heated below its recrystallization temperature. Casting has high compressive strength when compared with forging.
One of the differences between forging and casting is that the Fatigue strength of casting is less while fatigue strength in forging products is high. The imperfection or directional defect improves in forging while in casting it sometimes deteriorates due to little mistakes.
Items produced with forging operations are more reliable as compared with items produced with casting. Another great difference between forging and casting is that forging provides greater tensile strength to the object than casting.
Forging is less tedious as compared with casting. Forging doesn’t require secondary finishing but in casting secondary finishing is required to get the desired dimension. A forged object is more accurate than casting. Forging gives greater productivity than casting. In forging, fewer materials are wasted as it requires no secondary finishing but in casting wastage of material is more as secondary finishing is required.
A high degree of surface finish is obtained in forging but not so in casting. The cost of materials and production time is less in forging but in casting operations, the cost and production time are much.
Forging vs Casting in Tabular Form
| Forging | Casting | |
| Definition | Shaping metal using compressive forces | Pouring molten metal into a mold to shape it |
| Process | Metal is deformed through hammering, pressing, or rolling | Metal is melted, poured into a mold, and allowed to solidify |
| Material State | Solid | Liquid |
| Strength | Higher, due to grain refinement and deformation | Lower, potential for porosity and defects |
| Grain Structure | Oriented, continuous, and refined | Random and potentially disrupted |
| Complexity | Limited to simpler shapes | Can create complex shapes and intricate details |
| Surface Finish | Generally requires further machining | Can achieve smooth finish with appropriate mold design |
| Cost | Typically higher due to labor and tooling | Can be lower for large production runs |
| Size Limitations | Limited by the capacity of forging equipment | Can cast very large or small parts |
| Applications | High-stress components like crankshafts, gears | Engine blocks, pipes, and complex parts |
| Heat Treatment | Often required to achieve desired properties | Usually involves heat treatment post-casting |
| Tooling | Dies and hammers | Molds (sand, die, investment) |
| Production Volume | Economical for medium to high volume | Economical for both low and high volume |